An innocent Jason Aguilar, a hardworking overseas employee in Qatar, was incarcerated for seven days and deported back to the Philippine. He was mistaken for Jason Aguilar Ivler, the suspect of the November 18, 2009 killing of a certain Renato Ebarle Jr. The traumatized OFW experienced humiliation and hardship because the real Jason Aguilar Ivler escaped and deliberately refused to surrender to authorities in regards to the offense he committed. This is the first injustice in the case of Ivler.
There are several indications in this case that may connote that he will attempt to obtain preferential treatment during his trial. His mother already sought the assistance of the US Embassy. Will Ivler be able to obtain preferential treatment because he is an American citizen and a former member of the US Marine corps? Is this media frenzy about his arrest paving the way for him to escape his charges?
Criminal Aliens
Ivler is facing criminal charges both in the US and in the Philippines.
Recently, Ivler was reported to be a fugitive of justice in the United States for failing to appear in court on charges of illegal drug use and possession with intent to sell.
After his arrest two weeks ago, Ivler is also facing charges under Philippine law for murder, illegal possession of firearms, resisting arrest and frustrated murder.
With criminal charges in both the US and the Philippines, there is apprehension that Ivler may find a way to escape and depart for the US. The mother even reportedly sought the assistance and representation of the American Embassy.
If Ivler were a Filipino immigrant in the US facing charges, the Philippine consulate may provide assistance during his trial. But as observed, the consulate’s assistance is more on ensuring that the Filipino nationals’ rights and interests are protected. There are no special treatments that are accorded to immigrants facing charges. It is anticipated with reservations that Ivler will not receive any preferential treatment and be treated as an ordinary criminal alien.
Factors Raised
The media had an extensive coverage of Ivler during his arrest in his home at Blue Ridge, Quezon City. The victim in the road rage shooting of whom Ivler is being charged for murder is not an ordinary citizen. Renato Victor Ebarle Jr. is the son of the Undersecretary of the Presidential Chief of Staff. On the other hand, Ivler claims, as reported, is also not an ordinary American citizen. He is known to be the nephew of a former celebrity singer Freddie Aguilar. Most interestingly Ivler was also a former member of the US Marine Corps who was formerly deployed in Iraq before he was discharged.
But unlike Lance Corporal Daniel Smith, Ivler is no longer in active military service. Neither is he assigned in the Philippines under the Visiting Forces Agreement. Unfortunately for Ivler, he does not have the protection of the provisions of the VFA. He is not expected to be under the custody of the American Embassy pending his legal proceedings on the offenses that are charged against him.
The fact that he is related to a celebrity is not a favorable factor to his case. In fact, he is best described in the song, popularized by his uncle, “Anak” where his stubbornness had caused his mother to bear the embarrassment and humiliation of his arrest before millions of viewers. Had he surrendered voluntarily and not escaped from authorities he would have prevented unnecessary spending on government resources to arrest an innocent victim from Qatar and prevented injuries to special agents to the National Bureau of Investigation (NBI).
Since Ivler had failed attempts to escape from authorities, there are speculations that he may also try to evade his prosecution or detention. The circumstances of his case may not be favorable but just like any suspect in any criminal case, Ivler is entitled to his rights. He will be afforded the right to his hearing.
Compared to Spain, the United States does not have a treaty with the Philippines that allows transfer of criminal aliens’ incarceration to their home state. Ivler’s case is not similar to the case of Larranaga, a Spanish national convicted of rape. Larranaga was allowed to depart the Philippines to continue his detention in a Spanish prison.
A number of Filipino immigrants are also incarcerated in US prisons and serving sentence for crimes that they have committed. I have yet to see the cuddling by the Philippine government of a convicted Filipino immigrant languishing in jail for violation of criminal or immigration law.
The strict policy against criminal aliens is apparent in the US. The immigration law contains harsh provisions against criminal aliens especially those convicted of violent offenses. Despite serving sentence based on the criminal conviction and no matter how far back the offense was committed, the Immigration and Customs Enforcement is mandated to incarcerate and deport the alien after completion of his criminal sentence. This is also the same policy that is being expressed by the Philippine government where they publicly mentioned that Ivler is going to be tried first in Philippine Courts before he is sent back to the United States to face his criminal charges before the criminal courts in Reno, Nevada.
All citizens and aliens alike are all expected to respect the law. The government is mandated to defend Philippine law and sovereignty against aliens who are convicted of committing crimes against Filipino nationals. The celebrity status, the fact that Ivler is an American and a former member of the US Marine Corps are of no consequence and immaterial to his defense. Justice must be served and the rule of the law must be upheld. But in these times of uncertainty, it remains to be seen how the wheels of justice will turn for the families of the murdered victim.
(Tancinco may be reached at law@tancinco.com or at 887 7177 or 721 1963).